Hot Issues
spacer
The property cycle and the economy
spacer
How financial advice helps create wealth.
spacer
7 money personalities you may identify with or want to avoid
spacer
Are shares expensive?
spacer
How's Australia doing statistically?
spacer
Super investment options – what’s right for you?
spacer
Here's how to lead a happier life
spacer
What happened to all the worries about rising inflation and bond yields? Goldilocks, tariffs, Turkey & other things
spacer
Is it better to buy an investment property or home first?
spacer
Nine keys to successful investing
spacer
This information will turn you into a fireside expert.
spacer
How Australians will use their tax return
spacer
Lessons from the blue zones: secrets of a long life
spacer
Trumponomics and investment markets
spacer
Tools for budgeting, cash flow, Super and more ….
spacer
How much super should I have at my age?
spacer
How tax deductible personal super contributions work
spacer
The rise of the gig economy and side gigs (thanks to technology)
spacer
Statistics for all Australians
spacer
Watch out for tax scams
spacer
After the Australian household debt and east coast housing booms
spacer
Now’s the time for tax planning
spacer
Why it pays to contribute to your partner's super
spacer
Australia by numbers – Update
spacer
How to deal with financial stress – nearly 1 in 3 affected
spacer
Federal Budget 2018 – Overview
spacer
Your Budget
spacer
4 components of our 2018 Federal Budget
spacer
US China trade war fears – Q & A
spacer
Tools to help you manage your financial position are available on our site.
spacer
7 ways to boost your super
spacer
Australians reveal their priority goals
spacer
Australia by numbers – Update
spacer
Your retirement questions answered
spacer
How to make money by turning your unwanted goods into cash
spacer
Our website is really our digital office.
spacer
Bitcoin – is it really for you?
spacer
Spread your money, reduce risk
spacer
Love and money? It’s not about control
spacer
The pullback in shares - seven reasons not to be too concerned
spacer
Australia. All you need to know to be the expert.
spacer
Australian’s love affair with debt - how big is the risk?
spacer
5 ways to keep a cool head in a falling share market
spacer
2018 – a list of lists regarding the macro investment outlook
spacer
Sports lovers enjoy better financial fitness
spacer
Where Australia is at. Our leading indicators.
spacer
The year that was and the year ahead
spacer
Add some extra cash to your New Year
spacer
New year, new financial resolutions
spacer
Our Advent calendar for 2017
spacer
Where are we in the global investment cycle?
spacer
Australia's vital statistics
spacer
12 ways to enjoy summer without spending a fortune
spacer
One in three Aussies travel without protection
spacer
Digital payment options could see you spend more this Christmas
spacer
If you’ve always thought property prices only go up…
spacer
Will Australian house prices crash?
spacer
Where are we in the global investment cycle and what's the risk of a 1987 style crash?
spacer
Money steps for women
spacer
Resources on our site to help you, your family and your friends.
spacer
Australian Dietary Guidelines and healthy eating chart (PDF)
spacer
How to retire, your way
spacer
Prepare for retirement without missing out today
spacer
Be the boss of your cash
spacer
The Australian economy bounces back again
spacer
Should you lend money to family?
spacer
Money mistakes people make in their 50s and 60s
spacer
Australian Dietary Guidelines and healthy eating chart (PDF)
spacer
Eight steps to improved cashflow... and lifestyle
spacer
Powerful Budgeting, cash flow and Super Tools available on our site.
spacer
5 ways Australians will use their tax return this year
spacer
Australia's leading causes of death - ABS
spacer
The threat of war with North Korea
spacer
Six traits of Australians living the dream
spacer
The break higher in the Australian dollar is likely to be limited
spacer
Money can buy you happiness, you’re just spending it wrong
spacer
Key Economic Indicators, 2017 – updated
spacer
Helping your kids buy a home
spacer
From Goldilocks to taper tantrum 2.0
spacer
What’s your debt age?
spacer
Doing a budget is a good idea but ....
spacer
Planning is the key to making it financially
spacer
What to do when you come into money
spacer
Managing your money when you move in together
spacer
Reduce your bills with these household items
spacer
It pays to contribute to your partner's super
spacer
How to cope with losing independence
spacer
Transition to retirement income streams
spacer
The Australian economy hits another rough patch
spacer
Watch out for tax scams
spacer
The three core pillars of this year's budget
spacer
Federal Budget - 2017-18 - Overview
spacer
Federal Budget - 2017-18 - Budget documents
spacer
Make the most of the current super caps
spacer
Five, four, three… it’s not too late to get more in super
spacer
Super changes are coming
spacer
What’s your debt age?
spacer
Australian cash rate on hold
spacer
Super changes this financial year - Dr Shane Oliver - video
spacer
The door is closing on super’s current caps
spacer
Is Donald Trump's honeymoon with investors over?
spacer
Estate planning and why you need a super plan
spacer
What does a comfortable retirement look like?
spacer
Give your career a health check
spacer
Super changes from July 2017
spacer
Changes to the Age Pension assets test
spacer
Keep your money safe over the silly season
spacer
Looking ahead at 2017
spacer
Review of 2016, outlook for 2017 - looking better despite the political noise
spacer
Merry Christmas for 2016, a Happy New Year and a prosperous 2017.
spacer
54.2 million worries
spacer
Five tips for happy healthy ageing
spacer
Thinking about managing your own super?
spacer
Sending more to the tax office than you should?
spacer
Government pulls back on proposed changes to super
spacer
Market Update - What to consider when investing in a low return world
spacer
Stop!! Don't do a paper Budget, use our online budgeting tools instead.
spacer
Oliver's Insight - Megatrends
spacer
Value of Advice
spacer
A growing family doesn't have to blow the budget
spacer
Blinded by optimism
spacer
Thinking about managing your own super?
spacer
The investment outlook - it's not all that bad!
spacer
What’s your biggest obstacle to financial success?
spacer
Ageing Parents
spacer
Should you own the roof over your head?
spacer
Be a senior entrepreneur on your own terms!
spacer
Brexit and other key developments
spacer
Brexit wins
spacer
Commentary on major issues - AMP
spacer
Five money habits for a happy financial year
spacer
Remember to factor in parental subsidies at tax time
spacer
Are grandparents giving too much?
spacer
2016-17 Federal Budget - AMP
spacer
2016 Budget in detail
spacer
How (and why) to talk to your adult children about insurance
spacer
Procrastination: Just do it. Eventually.
spacer
Why Australian property won't collapse
spacer
The Lucky Country holding up pretty well
spacer
Have we reached the bottom?
spacer
The evolution of the Chinese consumer
spacer
Retirement rolls around faster than you think
spacer
Pressed for time?
spacer
Changes to the Age Pension assets test
spacer
Women are building financial intelligence
spacer
Heirlooms no more
spacer
Initial market falls precede stronger returns - Shane Oliver
spacer
What exactly is income protection insurance and do I need it?
spacer
A rough start to the year, which could have further to go
spacer
Aged Care - Changes to Assessment of Rental Income
spacer
A bump in the road, then a new start
spacer
New year, new start – are you ready for retirement?
spacer
Review of 2015, outlook for 2016 - Dr Shane Oliver
spacer
We wish you a Merry Christmas for 2015 and a Happy New Year
spacer
Go easy on the plastic over Christmas
spacer
Resolutions for a wealthy future
spacer
The Australian dollar doing what it normally does - overshoot. Dr Shane Oliver
spacer
How to manage volatility in a low return world
spacer
The Australian economy - more help will be needed. Dr Shane Oliver
spacer
Insurance through my super
spacer
Four tactics to build an investment portfolio
spacer
The demand for global infrastructure
spacer
Help achieve your investment goals with dynamic asset allocation
spacer
The Power of Budgeting
spacer
Jump retirement hurdles with a coach
spacer
Preparing for the time of your life
spacer
A Super Loan for all reasons
spacer
Making a smooth transition
spacer
Budget 2015 - some professional opinions
spacer
Australian Government - Budget 2015
spacer
Achieving a comfortable retirement
spacer
Is off-the-plan on the money?
spacer
Should I take my super as a lump sum or not?
spacer
Do you have a key person in your business?
spacer
Tips for success in a competitive job market
spacer
All you need to know about buying at auction
spacer
To sell or not to sell?
spacer
Saving in a material world
Are shares expensive?

Dr Shane Oliver
Head of Investment Strategy and Chief Economist 
AMP Capital 
October 2018

       

 

Key points

  • Starting point valuations for shares matter a lot in terms of medium-term return potential and vulnerability to share market falls. Basically, the cheaper the better.
  • Developed market shares are not dirt cheap (and haven’t been for several years) but on most measures they are not at overvalued extremes. US shares are most at risk, but other markets are reasonable.

Introduction

Some commentators claim shares are way overvalued and so a crash is inevitable. As always, it’s a lot more complicated, but given the current turbulence in share markets it’s worth having a look at whether share markets are expensive or not as a guide to how vulnerable we are to further falls. More broadly, valuation measures provide a guide to future return potential.

Why valuation matters - the cheaper the better

First a bit of background on valuation. A valuation measure for an asset is basically a guide to whether it’s expensive or cheap compared to the income it generates. Simple valuation measures are price to earnings ratios (PEs) for shares (the lower the better) and yields, ie the ratio of pidends, rents or interest payments to the value of the asset (the higher the better). An obvious example of where the starting point valuation matters critically is cash. For some years now, bank term deposit rates have been historically low meaning returns are low and value is poor.

For government bonds the yield is similarly a good guide to value. Over the medium term the main driver of the return a bond investor will get is what bond yields were when they invested. While the relationship is not perfect, it can be seen in the next chart - which shows a scatter plot of Australian 10-year bond yields (horizontal axis) against subsequent 10-year returns from Australian bonds based on the Composite All Maturities Bond index (vertical axis) – that the higher the bond yield, the higher the subsequent 10-year return from bonds.

Australian bonds - the higher the bond yield the better

Source: Global Financial Data, Bloomberg, AMP Capital

Again, despite rising a bit in the last two years, bond yields remain low so low returns should be expected from bonds.

For shares a similar relationship holds. The following chart shows a scatter plot of the PE ratio for US shares since 1900 (horizontal axis) against subsequent 10-year total returns (ie pidends and capital growth) from shares. While it is not as smooth as with bonds as there is more involved in shares, it indicates a negative relationship, ie when share prices are relatively high compared to earnings subsequent returns tend to be relatively low.

US shares - the lower the PE the better

Source: Global Financial Data, Bloomberg, AMP Capital

The next chart shows the same for Australian shares. Again, there is the expected negative relationship between the level of the PE and subsequent total returns (based on the All Ords Accumulation index).

Australian shares - the lower the PE the better

Source: RBA, Global Financial Data, AMP Capital

The key is that the starting point valuation matters. The higher the yield (or the lower the PE) the better.

Complications to be aware of

Of course, there are several pitfalls with valuation measures that investors should be aware of:

  • Sometimes assets are cheap for a reason (value traps). This is more often associated with inpidual shares, eg, a tobacco company subject to an impending law suit. These traps can really only be picked up by thorough research.
  • Valuation measures are a poor guide to timing. Eg, if an investor sold shares short in 1996 when Fed Chair Greenspan warned of “irrational exuberance” they would have lost out as shares rose for another four years. Australian residential property has been overvalued for almost 15 years but that’s been no guide to timing a fall in home prices. The key is to have a thorough investment process that depends on more than just valuations.
  • There is a huge range of share market valuation measures. For example, the “earnings” in the PE calculation can be earnings reported over the last 12 months, consensus earnings expectations for the year ahead or earnings that have been smoothed to remove cyclical distortions. All have their pros and cons. For example, the historic PE is based on actual data with no forecasting, but it can give the wrong signal during a recession as earnings may collapse more than share prices and so the PE may not give a buy signal.
  • Finally, the appropriate level of valuation can vary depending on the environment. For example, in a period of low inflation and low interest rates it’s well-known that assets can trade on lower yields as the interest rate/yield structure in the economy falls. This in turn means higher PEs. So low inflation, say down to around 2%, can be good for shares via higher PEs. But if inflation goes from “low” to deflation it can be bad as it tends to be associated with poor growth and so shares trade on lower PEs.

The message from all this is that share market valuation is important, but you ideally need to assess it along with other indicators if you are trying to time market moves. The key is to acknowledge that when a range of valuations measures are at an extreme then they are probably providing a signal that should not be ignored.

So what are current share market valuations signalling

Let’s start with price to earnings ratios using historic earnings, ie, earnings reported for the last 12 months. In the US, this PE is currently around 21 times which is consistent with subdued medium-term returns going by the second scatter plot on the previous page. But in Australia at around 15.3 times it’s consistent with reasonable medium term returns according to the third scatter plot on the previous page. Of course, current levels for historic PEs in the US and Australia have both been associated with a very wide range in terms of subsequent returns historically. Furthermore, PEs based on historic earnings are not totally reliable given the cyclical volatility in reported earnings.

Given this, calculating the price to earnings ratio using 12 month ahead projected earnings are arguably more useful. These are shown in the next chart for global shares, the US and Australia. None are way out of line with their averages since the early 1990s but in a relative sense US shares on a forward PE of 16.1 times remain a bit expensive albeit less so than earlier this year, and global shares are a bit cheap trading on a forward PE of 14.2 times thanks to cheap markets outside the US.

Forward PEs are around long term averages

Source: Thomson Reuters, AMP Capital

In emerging countries, the average forward PE is quite low at around 10 times.

The next chart looks at price to earnings ratios calculated using a 10-year moving average of earnings, which is often referred to as the Shiller PE (after economist Robert Shiller) or the cyclically adjusted PE. On this measure US shares are clearly more expensive than since the tech boom. However, markets outside the US, including Europe and Australia, are not expensive at all. It should also be allowed that the 10-year moving average earnings calculation is distorted by the earnings slump a decade ago. As the 2008 and 2009 earnings slump starts to fall out of the calculation, the US Shiller PE will start to fall. But still there is better value elsewhere.

Cyclically adjusted price to earnings ratios

Source: Global Financial Data, AMP Capital

Finally, it’s worth looking at share market valuations that allow for the fact we are still in an environment of relatively low interest rates and bond yields. The next chart subtracts the 10-year bond yield for the US and Australia from their earnings yield (using forward earnings). This basically gives a sort of a proxy for the equity risk premium – the higher the better. While this gap is well down from its post GFC highs, it’s still reasonable, suggesting shares are still more attractive than bonds. Of course, this will change as bond yields drift higher, but as we have seen over the last two years since bond yields bottomed, this is likely to remain a relatively slow process.

Shares are still not expensive relative to bonds

Source: Thomson Reuters, AMP Capital

The overall impression is that measured against their own history developed country share markets are not dirt cheap, but they haven’t been for several years now and they are not at overvalued extremes. The main risk relates to the US share market, but other markets’ valuations are reasonable. So while the pull back in shares we have seen over the last few weeks could go further yet – as worries around the US interest rates, US/China trade, rising oil prices, problems in the emerging world, President Trump and the US mid-term elections and the Italian budget remain – at least most share markets are not trading at overvalued extremes which would potentially accentuate downside risks.

 

Dr Shane Oliver
Head of Investment Strategy and Chief Economist
AMP Capital


Important note: While every care has been taken in the preparation of this document, AMP Capital Investors Limited (ABN 59 001 777 591, AFSL 232497) and AMP Capital Funds Management Limited (ABN 15 159 557 721, AFSL 426455) make no representations or warranties as to the accuracy or completeness of any statement in it including, without limitation, any forecasts. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. This document has been prepared for the purpose of providing general information, without taking account of any particular investor’s objectives, financial situation or needs. An investor should, before making any investment decisions, consider the appropriateness of the information in this document, and seek professional advice, having regard to the investor’s objectives, financial situation and needs. This document is solely for the use of the party to whom it is provided.